Amsterdam: post 2

May 16, 2024 • 9:15 am

I’ve been fighting a bad cold as well as dealing with the fallout from our cancellation debacle at the University of Amsterdam, so I haven’t gotten out much. This is a great pity as the weather had been good, though now it’s turned rainy.

This evening I will give a talk on science vs. religion at Tilburg University, founded as a Catholic school in 1927. Now it’s only technically Catholic, and is described by Wikipedia as “a public research university specializing in the social and behavioral sciences, economics, law, business sciences, theology and humanities. . . ”

We have had no threats of disruption (Tilburg is a few hours south of Amsterdam), so I’m not worried about that. Tomorrow Maarten Boudry and I, plus perhaps a surprise guest or two, will tape the discussion that was deplatformed at the University of Amsterdam.

At any rate, here are a few snapshots from my limited incursions in Amsterdam.

I’m surprised that this is my third visit to Amsterdam, and up to now I’d missed the “Stolpersteine” (literally, “stumbling stones”) which one encounters from time to time in the pavement in front of houses. They’re easy to miss, which is why I haven’t seen them before. Wikipedia describes them like this:

. . . . a ten-centimetre (3.9 in) concrete cube bearing a brass plate inscribed with the name and life dates of victims of Nazi extermination or persecution. Literally, it means ‘stumbling stone’ and metaphorically ‘stumbling block’.

The Stolpersteine project, initiated by the German artist Gunter Demnig in 1992, aims to commemorate persons at the last place that they chose freely to reside, work or study (with exceptions possible on a case-by-case basis) before they fell victim to Nazi terror, forced euthanasia, eugenics, deportation to a concentration or extermination camp, or escaped persecution by emigration or suicide. As of June 2023, 100,000.Stolpersteine have been laid, making the Stolpersteine project the world’s largest decentralized memorial.

They mostly commemorate Jews, but are also laid for murdered Romani, Jehovah’s Witnesses, homosexuals, and others persecuted by the Nazis. Here are three I found within two blocks from where I’m staying (there is a pair representing a man and his wife):

It says, “Here lived Elisa Frederika De Jon van Biema, born 1901, abducted 1944 to Westerbork, killed January 27, 1945, Auschwitz.”  Westerbork was the infamous Dutch camp where detainees, including Anne Frank and her family, were kept until they were transferred to the concentration camps (in this case Auschwitz). Elisa was killed at 44.

Below are the stones for a Jewish man and his wife who were deported together; the man died at Westerbork and his wife at Auschwitz.  Prisoners were sent to other camps, too, like Sobibór.  All told, about 98,000 Jews were deported from Westerbork to the camps, and nearly all of them were immediately gassed upon arrival.

Although some people object because these small stones allow people to walk over memorials for dead Jews, I find them moving because, once you look for them, they are easy to find but distressingly common. The houses of the murdered, of course, are still there, so the memorials are ineffably evocative.

Another Jewish man and wife, arrested on April 8, 1943, and gassed at Sobibór only two weeks later.

On a lighter note, here are two pictures from the local “supermarket”, which is a market but much smaller than American supermarkets. Nevertheless, it has a huge supply of cheese, which of course is a speciality of the Netherlands. Look at all the different kinds of cheese!

If you follow this site, you know I always check out the cat food in markets, to see if there’s any local flavor to what they feed the moggies.  Here there was nothing special (France has an array of gourmet-named cat foods), but they did have paté. The label reads, “complete pet food for adult cats.”

And a takeout meal last night from the local Balinese restaurant: rice, beef, chicken, eggplant, beans, and mixed veggies:

Thursday: Hili dialogue

May 16, 2024 • 4:37 am

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili is concerned about chelicerate parasites:

Hili: These are worrying times.
A: That’s right but what’s on your mind?
Hili: Ticks.
.
.
In Polish:
Hili: Czasy są teraz niespokojne.
Ja: To prawda, ale co masz na myśli?
Hili: Kleszcze.

A long list of student demands

May 15, 2024 • 12:00 pm

I present this list of demands, coming from students in one Canadian university, without comment, but readers are welcome to weigh in below.  Click on the screenshot (taken from The Coast Halifax) to go to the article, and I’ll just re-post what the students are demanding at one school.

The list of demands below comes from students at Nova Scotia College of Art and Design (usually called NSCAD University), but the text gives shorter lists from two other universities.

Excerpt indented:

On Friday, May 10, student groups from four Halifax universities–NSCAD, Dal, King’s and SMU–formed a shared group online, called Students for the Liberation of Palestine – Kjipuktuk/Halifax. In a post, they call on their universities “to immediately disclose and divest from any investments that sustain settler-colonial projects, including the Zionist state known as Israel.”

As of May 12, three of these schools have issued specific demands of their own university through specific student groups. At NSCAD, the student union–SUNSCAD–and the Student Action Group released a series of 12 demands to their university, as follows:

We demand:

  1. Public disclosure of the entirety of the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design University investment portfolio.
  2. Immediate divestment from all weapons manufacturing, military supplying, and companies operating in Israel or the occupied Palestinian territories.
  3. In response to emails sent from Dr. Shannon regarding the rights and responsibilities for students and faculty to speak truth to power, and exercise their academic freedom: an apology from, and the resignation of, the President of NSCAD University, Dr. Peggy Shannon.
  4. Anti-oppression training for ALL faculty and administration at NSCAD, focusing particularly on Queerness, indigeneity, and anticolonialism.
  5. Free tuition for all students.
  6. Free housing for all students.
  7. The implementation of a Palestinian Art History course.
  8. A scholarship offering free tuition and housing for one student currently living in Palestine.
  9. That the NSCAD Board of Governors be made up entirely of students, faculty, and staff, with at least 50% +1 seat on the Board being held by students.
  10. That NSCAD university moves all its banking to a credit union.
  11. The immediate breaking of the lease of NSCAD with the Port Authority, regarding NSCAD’s Port campus, and a commitment of no financial dealings with the Port Authority going forward.
  12. That all funds divested through the process of realizing the above demands be reinvested in the rebuilding of universities from the Gaza Strip that have been destroyed.

h/t: Luana

In light of protests, UNC Chapel Hill cuts diversity funding and beefs up security funding

May 15, 2024 • 10:30 am

“Defund the police and fund DEI,” were common cries on campuses in the last few years. But, in at least one case, the funding directions have suddenly reversed.

As NBC News reports, this happened at the flagship campus of the University of North Carolina (UNC): UNC at Chapel Hill.  As I’ve reported, this was only the second university in America (after the University of Chicago) to adopt official institutional neutrality on ideological, political, or moral issues. (This is the equivalent of Chicago’s Kalven Report.) Sadly, while the school has adopted neutrality, it’s still violating it in several ways. So we can say that UNC Chapel Hill talks the talk, but still doesn’t completely walk the walk.

Curiously, the violations of Kalven UNC enacted involve just those that are now endangered for lack of funds: mandatory antiracism policies, including DEI initiatives. Click the headline below to read:

An excerpt:

North Carolina’s public university system considers a vote on changing its diversity policy, the system’s flagship university board voted Monday to cut funding for diversity programs in next year’s budget.

The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Board of Trustees approved a change that would divert $2.3 million of diversity funding to go toward public safety and policing at a special meeting to address the university’s budget. The board’s vote would only impact UNC-Chapel Hill’s diversity funding, which could result in the loss of its diversity office.

The vote to shift more funding to public safety comes as continued pro-Palestinian protests on UNC’s campus have resulted in several arrests in recent weeks. The budget committee vice-chair Marty Kotis said law enforcement has already been forced to react to protests, but they need more funding to keep the university “safe from a larger threat.”

“It’s important to consider the needs of all 30,000 students, not just the 100 or so that may want to disrupt the university’s operations,” Kotis said. “It takes away resources for others.”

It’s ironic that this tradeoff is apparently happening because of college protests (DEI was on the way out in many places before the war, anyway), for many of the protests are fueled by the DEI mentality, which sees Israel as a land of white colonialist oppressors. And yet the police are needed to ensure that the protests don’t produce any violence to people or university propertly. (To be sure, there has been almost no physical danger from either side, although Jewish students did attack the encampment at UCLA, and that may have followed a Jewish woman being stepped on and kicked by protestors.)

There’s more:

Last month, the statewide board’s Committee on University Governance voted to reverse and replace its DEI policy for 17 schools across the state. The change would alter a 2019 diversity, equity and inclusion regulation that defines the roles of various DEI positions — and it would appear to eliminate those jobs if the policy is removed.

The full 24-member board is scheduled to vote next week on the policy change. If the alteration is approved, it will take effect immediately.

Many of us have called for an end to diversity offices and diversity statements at colleges and universities on several grounds, including that of ineffective programs and compelled speech. But I’ve also argued that at least a few people in each school should be tasked with investigating and enforcing prohibitions against bigotry as well as harassment in the workplace.

h/t Jay

Jerry Seinfeld’s commencement address at Duke

May 15, 2024 • 8:30 am

Here’s Jerry Seinfeld’s 17-minute commencement address at Duke, which I don’t find nearly as funny as I’ve been told. It may be because he once responded this way when asked about his reported statement that he won’t do comedy at colleges any more:

“I hear that all the time,” Seinfeld said. “I don’t play colleges, but I hear a lot of people tell me don’t go near colleges — they’re so PC (politically correct).”

So he stays pretty much away from politics in this address, something he more or less had to do given the Zeitgeist, but that also took the edge off his humor.  To me, the “funny” bits aren’t funny, and the serious “advice” seems anodyne.

Fall in love with BIC pens and pizza crust? What’s that about?  “Keep your sense of humor”? Yes, but he evinces little of that in his talk.  “Work hard in life”?  Yes, but that’s trite—the stuff of many such addresses. It’s clear that he decided to steer clear of anything that could cause controversy, and the result is a phoned-in and unfunny shtick. It’s a pity. And he didn’t even have to be controversial; all he had to be was funny, but he seemed incapable of that.

Nevertheless, as the NYT reported, there was still some protest.

As Mr. Seinfeld, who has recently been vocal about his support for Israel, received an honorary degree, dozens of students walked out and chanted, “Free, free Palestine,” while the comedian looked on and smiled tensely.

Many in the crowd jeered the protesters. Minutes later, as the last of the protesters were filing out, he approached the mic. His first words were: “Thank you. Oh my God, what a beautiful day.”

In his commencement speech, Mr. Seinfeld was mostly cautious, opting for a tight comedic script interspersed with life advice instead of a full-on response to the protests against his presence.

Well, at least he wasn’t deplatformed because of his support for Israel!

Jesus ‘n’ Mo ‘n’ priapism

May 15, 2024 • 8:00 am

Today’s Jesus and Mo strip, called “parts” came with a link and a comment:

The original story is here.  Check out the photo of the naughty priest.

And the email from the artist added, “That priest’s mischievous face is the funniest thing about this story.”

Go see for yourself!  Click below to see the article.

An excerptfrom the story, which appeared in Metro:

Father Thomas McHale, priest at Our Blessed Lady Immaculate in Blackhill, Consett, County Durham, shocked his flock by claiming during his Good Friday sermon that Jesus died with an erection.

The 53-year-old American prelate told the roughly 100 gathered that execution by crucifixion would have sent all the blood rushing down to Christ’s lower body.

One dismayed worshipper told The Times: ‘He told people Jesus died with an erection. The church was shocked. There were young families there.’

Oy! Here’s the strip: both the barmaid and Mo both take the mickey out of Jesus.

Wednesday: Hili dialogue

May 15, 2024 • 5:03 am

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili is musing about the implications of atheism.

Hili: If there is no God I have to go and take a nap.
A: An interesting conclusion.
.
.
In Polish:
Hili: Jeśli Boga nie ma, to trzeba się przespać.
Ja: To interesujący wniosek.

Press release about our cancellation

May 14, 2024 • 9:45 am

Below is the press release (in two languages) describing the cancellation of our discussion by a group at the University of Amsterdam. That cancellation (or “deplatforming”) is described in my previous post.

This press release was sent out by the people who came together to organize my visit to the Netherlands involving two scheduled events. This visit was a private initiative, not the initiative of an organization.

The original is in Dutch, but there’s also an English translation, and since most readers here are anglophones, I put the latter version first.

In English:

Meeting at UvA with American professor emeritus Jerry Coyne and Maarten Boudry cancelled due to Palestine position

Earlier I had invited you to the meeting of betabreak, the discussion platform of the Faculty of Natural Sciences, Mathematics and Computer Science (FNWI) of the University of Amsterdam about a recent article by Dr. Coyne in the journal Skeptical Enquirer (https://skepticalinquirer.org/2023/06/the-ideological-subversion-of-biology/). The meeting was to take place this Friday in the FNWI-UvA building Science Park 904. Participating in the discussion would be, in addition to Jerry Coyne: Maarten Boudry (Flemish philosopher and skeptic) and Michael Richardson (Professor of Evolutionary developmental zoology at Leiden University).

The meeting’s organizer, Betabreak (https://www.betabreak.org/committee), called off the meeting because of Coyne and Boudry’s Palestine position. Betabreak indicated that many members of committee of Betabreak were uncomfortable giving Jerry Coyne and Maarten Boudry a stage given their position on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Betabreak’s committee also expressed concern about the impression a debate with Coyne and Boudry would make on Betabreak’s organization. Betabreak’s committee concluded that the debate with Boudry and Coyne could not take place given the current political climate.

Jerry Coyne and Maarten Boudry will discuss the article in the Skeptical Enquirer at another location on Friday without an audience. A video recording of this conversation will be made available via the Internet. The discussion participants are dismayed that the decision of betabreak of the FNWI of the UvA (https://www.betabreak.org/) to cancel a scientific discussion because of the political-societal views of the discussion participants leads to the fact that the discussion will take place in a private residence.

You are welcome to attend the conversation between Jerry Coyne and Maarten Boudry. Jerry Coyne and Maarten Boudry are available for questions about the situation.

More information about Jerry Coyne and Maarten Boudry can also be found on their website/weblog:

– Jerry Coyne: https://whyevolutionistrue.com/

– Maarten Boudry: https://maartenboudry.be/category/blog

In Dutch:

Bijeenkomst op UvA met Amerikaanse emeritus hoogleraar Jerry Coyne en Maarten Boudry afgezegd vanwege Palestina standpunt 

Eerder had ik u uitgenodigd voor de bijeenkomst van betabreak, het discussieplatform van de Faculteit der Natuurwetenschappen, Wiskunde en Informatica (FNWI) van de Universiteit van Amsterdam over een recente artikel van dr. Coyne in het tijdschrift Skeptical Enquirer (https://skepticalinquirer.org/2023/06/the-ideological-subversion-of-biology/). De bijeenkomst zou aanstaande vrijdag plaatsvinden in het FNWI-UvA gebouw Science Park 904. Aan het gesprek zouden deelnemen naast Jerry Coyne: Maarten Boudry (Vlaams filosoof en skepticus) en Michael Richardson (Professor of Evolutionary developmental zoology aan de Universiteit van Leiden).

De organisatie van de bijeenkomst, Betabreak (https://www.betabreak.org/committee), heeft de bijeenkomst afgeblazen vanwege het Palestina standpunt van Coyne en Boudry. Betabreak gaf aan dat veel leden van committee van Betabreak zich er niet prettig bij voelden om Jerry Coyne en Maarten Boudry een podium te geven gezien hun standpunt over het Palestijns-Israëlische conflict. Het committee van Betabreak gaf aan ook bezorgd te zijn over de indruk die een debat met Coyne en Boudry zou maken over de organisatie van Betabreak. Het committee van Betabreak komt tot de conclusie dat het debat met Boudry en Coyne niet kan doorgaan gezien het huidige politieke klimaat.

Jerry Coyne en Maarten Boudry zullen op een andere locatie op vrijdag zonder publiek met elkaar in discussie gaan over het artikel in de Skeptical Enquirer. Van dit gesprek zal een video-opname worden gemaakt die via internet beschikbaar zal worden gemaakt. De gespreksdeelnemers zijn ontsteld dat het besluit van betabreak van de FNWI van de UvA (https://www.betabreak.org/) om een wetenschappelijke discussie af te blazen vanwege de politiek-maatschappelijke opvattingen van de gespreksdeelnemers er toe leidt het gesprek in een privé woonhuis zal plaatsvinden.

U bent van harte welkom om aanwezig te zijn bij het gesprek tussen Jerry Coyne en Maarten Boudry. U kunt Jerry Coyne en Maarten Boudry dan ook vragen stellen over de situatie.

Meer informatie over Jerry Coyne en Maarten Boudry kunt u ook vinden op hun website / weblog: